Research, insights, and resources to help California parents navigate school performance, parental rights, and academic accountability.
Monday, October 05, 2026
The Growing Math Readiness Gap at UC Berkeley
Imagine paying thousands of dollars to attend one of the nation’s premier public universities, enrolling in a mathematics course and discovering that the professor has to go back and teach material that should have been mastered in middle school. One might expect that a student enrolled in calculus should be comfortable with fractions, algebra and other foundational mathematics.
UC Berkeley mathematics professor Zvezdelina Stankova says that is increasingly not the reality she encounters in her classrooms. In a recent essay, Stankova described students arriving at Berkeley who are sometimes five to eight years behind where they need to be mathematically. Instead of spending office hours discussing calculus, professors can find themselves reteaching fractions, basic algebra and linear equations—material that should have been mastered years earlier. Her observations are not simply about individual students struggling with a difficult subject; they point to a larger problem of whether a high school diploma and an impressive transcript necessarily demonstrate genuine academic readiness.
The numbers surrounding UC admissions make that question difficult to ignore. According to the University of California’s own 2026 Accountability Report, the share of entering freshmen with a weighted, capped high school GPA of 4.0 or higher increased from 53% in 2015 to 66% in 2025. During the same period, the percentage completing 25 or more UC-approved college-preparatory courses increased from 44% to 58%.
Those numbers would ordinarily suggest that incoming students are increasingly well prepared. Yet Stankova’s classroom experience tells a different story. Diagnostic testing of Berkeley Calculus I students found that before the UC system abandoned SAT and ACT requirements, approximately 71% of students tested as ready or nearly ready for calculus. In testing conducted from 2021 through 2023 using a different diagnostic, that figure had fallen to roughly 51%, reaching 44% in 2023. The proportion of students displaying severe deficiencies also increased dramatically.
That contrast raises an uncomfortable but important question: What exactly does a rising GPA tell us if students can earn excellent grades without demonstrating mastery of foundational skills? UC faculty have themselves documented evidence of grade inflation. A 2024 University of California Academic Senate committee report found that the percentage of A grades awarded increased at every UC campus when comparing 2015–16 with 2022–23, while average UC student GPAs also increased. At the same time, UC’s recent data show that students are entering the system with higher high school GPAs. None of this proves that every high school grade is inflated or that every student is inadequately prepared. But taken together with classroom diagnostics and professors’ experiences, it makes a compelling case that grades alone are not sufficient evidence of readiness for demanding college coursework.
This is why Stankova’s argument deserves serious consideration. The issue is not whether every student who struggles with mathematics should be denied admission to a four-year university. Nor is a standardized test capable of fixing the underlying problems in K–12 mathematics education. The issue is whether universities should have a reliable way to determine whether students are prepared for the academic demands of the programs they are entering. UC’s Academic Senate now recognizes that college readiness is a growing challenge and has begun an evidence-based review of undergraduate admissions, including whether standardized testing should once again play a role. The review is scheduled to produce recommendations during 2026–27.
Janet Napolitano served as the UC president from 2013-2020. In her final year as president, Napolitano initiated a systemwide review that ultimately led the Regents to suspend and then eliminate the use of SAT/ACT scores in UC undergraduate admissions.” Starting in the Fall of 2021, a transition policy eased from those testing requirements, though students could still submit the scores. For Fall of 2023 and 2024, campuses would become test-blind for admissions where scores could not be used in admission selection. This was done to appease leftist activists who claimed the exams were unfair on non-white students, but professors now say it’s fueled rampant grade inflation that’s flooding colleges with unqualified students.
The UC's Standard Testing Task Force report from January 2020 found that high-school GPA had become less predictive of college outcomes, and explicitly connected part of that decline to differences in grading standards and grade inflation among California high schools.
The task force brought up two concerns. First, under the banner of equity, SAT/ACT scores differed substantially by socioeconomic and demographic group, raising questions about whether their use perpetuated existing inequality. Second, high-school grades varied substantially among schools, and grade inflation had reduced their predictive value, making an additional standardized measure useful.
Students deserve better than discovering after enrollment that the credential they worked so hard to earn did not adequately prepare them for the next level. Professors deserve to be able to teach the courses they were hired to teach. And universities have a responsibility to be honest about what their admissions decisions mean. If a student is admitted to calculus, that student should have demonstrated the foundational mathematical knowledge necessary to learn calculus. If the evidence shows a growing gap between grades and actual mastery, the answer should not be to lower the academic expectations of the university. It should be to identify the gap earlier, communicate it honestly and give students the preparation they need before they reach a classroom where fractions have no business being the lesson of the day.
Your support empowers California families to reclaim transparency,
parental rights, and academic integrity in public schools.

Informed Parents, Informed Parents California, and OPT-OUT CA are dba’s of Informed Parents Silicon Valley, Inc., a Section 501(c)(3) charitable organization, EIN 87-2694564. Contributions are tax-deductible for income, gift, and estate taxes. Our IRS determination letter can be requested by emailing us at donations@ip-sv.org. Copyright 2026. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
